Evidence and Agency: Norms of Belief for Promising and Resolving

Evidence and Agency: Norms of Belief for Promising and Resolving

4.11 - 1251 ratings - Source

Evidence and Agency is concerned with the question of how, as agents, we should take evidence into account when thinking about our future actions. Suppose you are promising or resolving to do something that you have evidence is difficult for you to do. For example, suppose you are promising to be faithful for the rest of your life, or you are resolving to quit smoking. Should you believe that you will follow through, or should you believe that there is a good chance that you won't? If you believe the former, you seem to be irrational since you believe against the evidence. Yet if you believe the latter, you seem to be insincere since you can't sincerely say that you will follow through. Hence, it seems, your promise or resolution must be improper. Nonetheless, we make such promises and resolutions all the time. Indeed, as the examples illustrate, such promises and resolutions are very important to us. The challenge is to explain this apparent inconsistency in our practice of promising and resolving. To meet this challenge, Berislav MaruaAiiaA‡ considers a number of possible responses, including an appeal to 'trying', an appeal to non-cognitivism about practical reason, an appeal to 'practical knowledge', and an appeal to evidential constraints on practical reasoning. He rejects all these and defends a solution inspired by the Kantian tradition and by Sartre in particular: as agents, we have a distinct view of what we will do. If something is up to us, we can decide what to do, rather than predict what we will do. But the reasons in light of which a decision is rational are not the same as the reasons in light of which a prediction is rational. That is why, provided it is important to us to do something we can rationally believe that we will do it, even if our belief goes against the evidence.Let me now propose a schematic account of freedom. I hold that something is up to us if and only if we settle what happens and do so in light of our reasons.83 This account is schematic, because it does not offer an account of what it means toanbsp;...

Title:Evidence and Agency: Norms of Belief for Promising and Resolving
Author:Berislav Maru&ši&ć
Publisher:OUP Oxford - 2015-09-18


You Must CONTINUE and create a free account to access unlimited downloads & streaming